Kolkata: Calcutta High Court on Friday described as “painful” and “unnecessary” Trinamool MP Abhishek Banerjee’s comment on social media against its orders, but extended his interim protection from coercive action for an earlier remark till Jan 29, stressing that there had been “no alteration in the situation (necessitating the protection from arrest)”.Referring to Banerjee’s statement on the judiciary, Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya said, “Unnecessarily the petitioner (Banerjee) is drawing troubles… Comparative statements are being made about the orders passed during this period and the previous period (referring to the change in govt). Everybody who reads the newspaper knows it… If you are aggrieved by the order of court, appeal against it before the higher forum. But is it a way that a member of Parliament will make such a comment? Then what sort of message goes to the general public, who are his political followers?”The judge was referring to the MP’s comment on X, made after the HC on Thursday declined interim protection from coercive action to his aide, Sumit Roy, in four criminal cases. Banerjee wrote, “Justice cannot be the ruling party’s private privilege and the Opposition’s perpetual struggle. Relief seems to be reserved for BJP leaders… while the Opposition is left fighting for the rights guaranteed by the Constitution.”Although Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya expressed displeasure over Abhishek Banerjee’s remarks, he asked the state, “Considering the rule of contempt and established principle to be followed while drawing up a contempt proceeding, based on such a tweet (post on X), can it be construed as wilful, deliberate, contemptuous violation… Can it be a ground for refusing extension of interim protection (from arrest)? Can it be a ‘just’ thing to pass an order based on certain remarks made against the judiciary?”The judge asked the state whether there had been a change in circumstances requiring the court to deny an extension of the interim order.The case in which Banerjee’s interim protection was extended — for a third time, after May 21 and July 20 — was registered by Bidhannagar City Police for the MP’s comment that “DJ will be played” after the announcement of the assembly poll results on May 4.The state, represented by additional advocate generals (AAGs) Rajdeep Mazumder and Bilwadal Bhattacharya, stressed that the remarks allegedly made by Banerjee against the judiciary, including the HC, were strong enough to deny him interim protection.Mazumder submitted, “This person is repeatedly attacking the high court and the judiciary. Yesterday, your lordship refused to pass any interim order to his personal assistant, immediately a tweet was made against your lordship’s court. Whether your lordship will permit him to continue with the protection or not.”AAG Bhattacharya echoed this and further submitted that the remarks were “scurrilous and targeted, made by a person… who is supposed to be a lawmaker… Someone’s lack of education or far-sightedness cannot expose courts or judges to attacks”.Justice Bhattacharyya, however, observed, “The court does not find any alteration of situation requiring refusal to extend interim order, which was passed on May 21 and it is not demonstrated on behalf of state respondents that Banerjee is not cooperating with the probe. The interim order on July 20 stands extended till Jan 29.”
Join The Discussion